Unraveling the Layers of Truth: A Comprehensive Review of “Deposing Nathan” by Zack Smedley


“Deposing Nathan” by Zack Smedley, published in 2019, is a riveting exploration of identity, love, and the complex nature of truth. In this extensive review, we embark on a journey through the pages of Smedley’s novel, dissecting its narrative intricacies, character dynamics, and the nuanced exploration of sensitive themes.

I. Plot Overview:

“Deposing Nathan” centers on the life of Nathan Bishop, a high school senior, who finds himself in the midst of a legal deposition. The novel unfolds as Nathan recounts the events leading up to a life-altering incident, touching on themes of sexuality, faith, and the consequences of revealing one’s true self in a society that often struggles with acceptance.

A. Narrative Structure:

  1. Examine the narrative structure employed by Zack Smedley in “Deposing Nathan.”
  2. Discuss how the deposition format adds layers of tension, suspense, and introspection to the storytelling.

B. Character Development:

  1. Analyze the evolution of Nathan’s character throughout the novel.
  2. Discuss the challenges he faces, the decisions he makes, and the impact on his identity and relationships.

II. Zack Smedley’s Writing Style:

A. First-Person Perspective:

  1. Assess the effectiveness of the first-person perspective in “Deposing Nathan.”
  2. Discuss how the narrative choice contributes to the reader’s engagement with Nathan’s internal struggles and emotional journey.

B. Exploration of Sensitive Themes:

  1. Examine how Smedley approaches and navigates sensitive themes such as sexuality, faith, and acceptance.
  2. Discuss the author’s ability to handle these themes with nuance and empathy.

III. Themes of Sexuality and Faith:

A. Sexuality and Coming-of-Age:

  1. Delve into the novel’s exploration of Nathan’s sexuality and his coming-of-age journey.
  2. Discuss the challenges and triumphs he experiences in discovering and embracing his authentic self.

B. Religious Identity:

  1. Explore the portrayal of religious identity in “Deposing Nathan.”
  2. Discuss the intersection of faith and sexuality and the conflicts Nathan faces within the context of his religious beliefs.

IV. Character Relationships:

A. Friendships and Betrayals:

  1. Analyze the dynamics of Nathan’s friendships and how they shape the narrative.
  2. Discuss instances of loyalty, betrayal, and the complexities of adolescent relationships portrayed in the novel.

B. Romantic Relationships:

  1. Delve into the romantic relationships depicted in “Deposing Nathan.”
  2. Discuss the impact of love, acceptance, and the challenges faced by LGBTQ+ characters in the context of the story.

V. Emotional Impact on Readers:

A. Empathy and Connection:

  1. Discuss how “Deposing Nathan” elicits empathy from readers.
  2. Analyze the emotional connections formed between readers and the characters, particularly Nathan, as they navigate the challenges presented in the narrative.

B. Exploration of Mental Health:

  1. Explore the novel’s portrayal of mental health, particularly Nathan’s emotional struggles.
  2. Discuss how the narrative contributes to discussions surrounding mental health awareness and destigmatization.

VI. Critical Reception:

A. Literary Critic Reviews:

  1. Examine critical reviews of “Deposing Nathan” from literary critics.
  2. Discuss the strengths and potential criticisms identified by critics and how they align with or challenge the reviewer’s own assessment.

VII. Zack Smedley’s Body of Work:

A. Comparisons with Other Works:

  1. Explore how “Deposing Nathan” fits into Zack Smedley’s broader body of work.
  2. Discuss recurring themes, narrative styles, or unique elements that distinguish this novel within Smedley’s bibliography.

B. Impact on Young Adult Fiction:

  1. Analyze Smedley’s impact on the young adult fiction genre.
  2. Discuss how his work contributes to the evolving landscape of LGBTQ+ representation and exploration of sensitive themes in young adult literature.

VIII. Cultural and Social Relevance:

A. Representation in Literature:

  1. Delve into the cultural and social relevance of “Deposing Nathan” in the context of LGBTQ+ representation in literature.
  2. Discuss the novel’s contribution to promoting diverse narratives and perspectives.

IX. Reader Recommendations and Audience:

A. Target Audience:

  1. Identify the target audience for “Deposing Nathan” based on themes, tone, and narrative content.
  2. Discuss how the novel resonates with its intended readership and its potential appeal to readers interested in LGBTQ+ literature, coming-of-age stories, and explorations of identity.

B. Reader Recommendations:

  1. Offer recommendations to readers who may be drawn to the themes explored in “Deposing Nathan.”
  2. Provide insights into the types of readers who are likely to find the novel compelling and resonate with its portrayal of personal and societal struggles.

X. Conclusion:

In conclusion, “Deposing Nathan” by Zack Smedley emerges as a compelling and emotionally charged exploration of identity, love, and the complex interplay of faith and sexuality. Through its powerful narrative, nuanced characters, and sensitive handling of themes, Smedley has crafted a novel that resonates with readers on multiple levels. Whether navigating the challenges of adolescence, the pursuit of self-discovery, or the quest for acceptance, “Deposing Nathan” stands as a testament to the enduring power of literature to reflect, question, and illuminate the multifaceted aspects of the human experience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *